John Leland opposed slavery because it destroyed the slaves
family life, it undermined the character of both master and slave, and it
deprived the slave of religious liberty. Concerning the
morality of slavery, he argued:
"The whole scene of slavery is pregnant with enormous
evils. On the master's side, pride, haughtiness, domination,
cruelty, deceit, and indolence and on the side of the slave, ignorance,
servility, fraud, perfidy, and despair. If these, and many other
evils, attend it, why not liberate them at once? Would to Heaven
this were done! The sweets of rural and social life will never be
well enjoyed, until it is the case." (The Writings of
John Leland, ed. L. F. Greene, New York: Arno Press, 1969, pp.
96-97)
He thought slavery was worse for the master than for the slave,
saying, "The state of slaves is truly pitiable, and that of
the master, in some things, more so." (p. 96)
Leland opposed federal laws that counted slaves as "three-fifths
of a man, and two-fifths of a brute." (p. 96) He
insisted that:
"Slavery, in its best appearance, is a violent deprivation of
the rights of nature, inconsistent with republican government, destructive
of every humane and benevolent passion of the soul, and subversive to the
liberty absolutely necessary to ennoble the human mind." (p. 174)
In 1790 the Baptist General Committee of Virginia passed a
resolution against slavery that was proposed by Leland. The
resolution read:
"Resolved, That slavery is a violent deprivation of the rights
of nature and inconsistent with a republican government, and therefore
recommend it to our brethren to use every legal measure to extirpate this
horrid evil from the land; and pray Almighty God that our honorable
Legislature may have it in their power to proclaim the great Jubilee
consistent with the principles of good policy."
The Roanoke Association took immediate exception to the resolution,
saying it was not "unanimously clear" whether or not slavery
opposed the gospel. As opposition to his resolution was being
mobilized and as preaching invitations for the evangelist ended, Leland
left Virginia in 1791 and returned to his home in New England. In
1792 the General Committee rescinded Leland's resolution and passed a
resolution declaring the issue of slavery "belonged to the
Legislative Body" -- thereby advising abolitionists to focus their
energies outside the church in the political arena.